Background
Effective regulation protects the rights and safety of citizens, supports fair markets and ensures the delivery of public goods and services meets defined standards. Regulation is distinct from direct government provision or commissioning of services, because it relies on using incentives and sanctions to drive behaviour change in individuals or organisations outside of government’s direct oversight.
When regulation fails, it can have severe consequences for public finances, public safety, the economy as a whole or the environment.
The regulatory landscape in Jersey has developed over time, sometimes in response to specific events. There are a number of independent bodies set up to deliver regulatory functions, for example the Jersey Care Commission and the Jersey Competition Regulatory Authority. The States of Jersey website sets out areas of regulated activity across Jersey covering services ranging from agriculture to waste management. For some services, regulation is provided by an independent body, but for other services, for example construction, regulatory functions are undertaken by Government, or by Government contracting with a third party to provide regulatory services to the Island.
Effective regulation requires:
Clarity and simplicity: regulations should be clear and straightforward, making it easy for individuals and organisations to understand their obligations. This reduces compliance costs and enhances adherence to the rules.
Proportionality: the regulatory approach should be proportionate to the risks involved. This means that the level of regulation should correspond to the potential likelihood and impact of non-compliance, ensuring that resources are allocated efficiently.
Consistency: regulations should be consistent across different sectors and over time. This helps build trust and predictability in the regulatory environment, allowing businesses and individuals to plan accordingly.
Stakeholder engagement: effective regulation involves engaging with stakeholders, including businesses, consumers, and civil society, to gather input and feedback. This collaborative approach can lead to better-designed regulations that meet the needs of all parties involved.
Monitoring and enforcement: there should be robust mechanisms for monitoring compliance and enforcing regulations. This includes having the necessary resources and authority to take action against non-compliance, which is crucial for maintaining the integrity of the regulatory framework.
The full costs of regulation go beyond the operating costs of regulators. Effective regulation maximises the benefits while minimising compliance costs and unintended consequences. The UK National Audit Office (NAO) Good Practice Guidance Principles of Effective Regulation (May 2021) sets out the four principles of effective regulation (Exhibit 1).
Exhibit 1 Principles of regulation: a learning cycle

Source: National Audit Office Good Practice Guidance – Principles of Effective Regulation May 2021
Scope
The audit has evaluated the current landscape of regulation in Jersey to identify whether there are any overlaps or gaps in the design of regulation to achieve public policy aims in an effective way.
The focus has been on the design of regulation and whether the design supports the delivery of effective regulation. It has not analysed the markets or issues being regulated or considered the intervention mechanisms being used in practice.
The areas of regulation considered include:
- public services
- public health
- environmental standards
- planning
- building standards; and
- economic.
Conclusions
The regulatory landscape is complex and complicated. Gaining an understanding of how the regulatory system as a whole operates is not easy to achieve. Regulation in Jersey has developed over a long period and has been driven by different imperatives. In many cases regulation has been reactive, created in isolation of other regulation. This has resulted in ‘layering’ of regulations and potential areas of regulatory duplication. In comparison with other jurisdictions Jersey also has some areas where there are potential gaps in regulation.
At the time of the audit, Jersey had no established criteria or framework against which to make decisions about what to regulate and how, and what not to regulate. The C&AG understands that the Council of Ministers has since approved a Regulatory Framework that was published on 18 November 2026. To date there has been no established process to routinely take stock of Jersey’s regulatory requirements – individually and as a whole – in the context of clear evidence of need, based on an up to date understanding of current and emerging risk. This makes it more likely that relatively low value and even obsolete regulations are still in place, that parts of the regulatory system do not work well together, and that important regulations are inadequate or missing.
Currently, roles and responsibilities for regulation are fragmented and there has been no coherent approach. Until the appointment of a Minister for Planning and Regulation in July 2026, there has been no single point of regulatory leadership. The new Minister is clear about the need to implement an evidence-based system and process of regulation, designed to address specific opportunities, issues and risks. At the time of the audit an ambitious work programme was being discussed although no timetabled or prioritised plan was yet established.
There is wide variation in how regulators report against their aims and objectives. All independent regulators publish annual reports, but the content of these is not consistent. Government and non-Ministerial departments vary in the extent to which they publicly report on performance. Currently, there is no clear set of minimum criteria against which to report performance and enable comparison across regulators and with other jurisdictions.
The appointment of the Minister for Planning and Regulation in July 2026 has provided a single point of regulatory leadership. The Government is developing an ambitious programme to introduce an evidence‑based framework for regulation. This provides an opportunity to redefine regulation around the minimum assurance requirements needed to minimise harm and protect the public interest. Developing an evidence and risk based approach also provides the opportunity to ensure regulation in Jersey is proportionate, targeted, consistent and accountable.
Jersey does not have a coherent approach to designing and implementing regulation. The landscape is complex and fragmented and does not allow for the delivery of value for money to be assured.
